Which baseline measurement should Millbrook adopt?

type
research-question
workflow status
investigating
settles when
The council writes one method into the policy and repeats the same nine stations at the same season.

Question: should the town measure skyglow with the astronomy society's stations, with a Bortle class, or with a lamp-level inventory?

Options on the table:

  • Nine fixed stations + sky-quality meter. Repeatable, cheap, already done once. Gives zenith brightness but says nothing about glare or light trespass.
  • Bortle class. Shared language, but coarse and observer-dependent. The advisory note warns against it as a target.
  • Lamp inventory and lumen budget. Directly actionable, but measures installed light, not what leaves the fitting or where it lands.

Current reading: use all three for different jobs — stations for the before-and-after claim, lumen budget for procurement, Bortle only as a gloss. The advisory note recommends local measurement over modelling (s. 2, p. 5).

What would settle it: a council decision recorded in policy. Until then the spring survey is a one-off baseline, not a monitoring programme.