Does the Bortle class improve measurably after a retrofit?
- type
- research-question
- workflow status
- open
- settles when
- The same nine stations are re-measured on a comparable night after the pilot, and the readings are compared station by station.
Question: if twelve Market Row lamps are replaced and dimmed, does anything change at station S4, and does the change survive a repeat night?
What the baseline says: S4 read 18.7 mag/arcsec², roughly Bortle 7, against 21.6–21.7 at the southern and eastern edges (survey, table 2). A 23% cut in the lumen budget on one row is a small intervention against that range.
The measurement problem: one night, consumer meters, no calibration. A sub-0.2 magnitude change would be inside the noise. The advisory note warns that local skyglow is poorly predicted by luminaire specifications.
What would settle it: a pre-registered repeat, same stations, same season, three readings each, and a stated smallest effect worth claiming. Without that, the class will move on paper and prove nothing.
Related: measurement question, Millbrook Astronomical Society.