Does 2200 K reduce insect attraction enough to standardise?
- type
- research-question
- workflow status
- investigating
- settles when
- A second independent trial at equal lumens reports the same direction, and a council-commissioned survey repeats it on two Millbrook streets.
Question: should the council go below its 3000 K policy floor for all replacement lamps, or keep 2200 K for the pilot only?
What supports it: the Wren Valley trial reports attraction at 2200 K at about 38% of 4000 K, with 3000 K at 86% (s. 3.1, table 3). The advisory note names 2200 K as the safer end where colour rendering is not critical.
What cuts against it: one site, one season, moths only. Three volunteers, twelve nights. The trial's own authors call the result directional. Colour rendering for CCTV and face recognition is not recorded anywhere in this map.
What would settle it: the second independent trial, plus a local repeat. Until then, 2200 K on twelve Market Row lamps is an experiment, and the policy floor should stand.
Related: correlated colour temperature, Wren Valley Ecology Group, retrofit sequencing.